A Family Business Built on Faith, Play & Purpose
Play and Pray Kids was born from a simple belief: that the best toys do more than entertain — they nurture, inspire, and point little hearts toward something greater.
How It All Began
It started in our living room. As parents of three, we found ourselves searching endlessly for toys and gifts that were both genuinely fun and aligned with our family's faith values. The options were either too secular or too boring — never both joyful and meaningful.
So in 2018, we opened Play and Pray Kids — a small shop with a big heart. We hand-picked every item on our shelves, asking one simple question: 'Would we give this to our own kids?' If the answer was yes, it earned a spot.
Today we serve families across every age and stage, from newborns to tweens, with a curated collection of toys, games, books, clothing, and gifts that spark imagination and nurture faith. We're still that same family — just with a lot more shelf space.
What We Believe
These aren't just words on a wall — they're the reason we show up every day.
Faith-Centered
Every product we carry reflects our commitment to nurturing children's faith and character alongside their creativity and curiosity.
Joyful Play
We believe play is sacred. The best toys spark imagination, build confidence, and create memories that last a lifetime.
Family First
We're a family business serving families. We treat every customer like a neighbor — with warmth, honesty, and genuine care.
Thoughtfully Curated
No filler, no junk. Every item is hand-selected for quality, safety, and the ability to delight kids and reassure parents.
Meet the Family
Behind every toy on our shelves is a real family who cares deeply about yours.
Sarah Mitchell
Co-Founder & Chief Joy Officer
Mom of three, former kindergarten teacher, and the heart behind every product pick. Sarah believes every child deserves toys that make them feel seen and loved.
David Mitchell
Co-Founder & Operations
Dad, builder, and the one who keeps the shelves stocked and the lights on. David handles everything from vendor relationships to making sure your order arrives with a smile.
Come Visit Us In Store
Our shop is a place where kids can touch, explore, and fall in love with play. We'd love to meet your family.